Your inspiring proposal title【免费下载链接】minikubeRun Kubernetes locally项目地址: https://gitcode.com/gh_mirrors/mi/minikubeFirst proposed:Authors: $full_name (github-handle), $full_name2 (github_handle2)Reviewer PrioritiesPlease review this proposal with the following priorities:Does this fit with minikubes principles?Are there other approaches to consider?Could the implementation be made simpler?Are there usability, reliability, or technical debt concerns?Please leave the above text in your proposal as instructions to the reader.Summary(1 paragraph) What are you proposing, and why is it important to users and/or developers?GoalsA bulleted list of specific goals for this proposalHow will we know that this proposal has succeeded?Non-GoalsA bulleted list of what is out of scope for this proposalListing non-goals helps to focus the discussionDesign Details(2 paragraphs) A short overview of your implementation idea, containing only as much detail as required to convey your idea.If you have multiple ideas, list them concisely.Include a testing plan to ensure that your enhancement is not broken by future changes.Alternatives ConsideredAlternative ideas that you are leaning against.模板只解决写什么而放哪里由目录约定决定。仓库中 enhancements/ 目录按生命周期分为三个子目录 - proposed/正在评审中的提案命名规范为 YYYYMMDD-标题/如 [proposed/20200424-scheduled-shutdown/20200424-scheduled-shutdown.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/c8be3abf3389d1abb54831058c2d009b) - implemented/已经实现并合入的提案如 [implemented/20210624-flake-rate/flake-rate.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/1cbd12cf642844c384f9bd92accf58c3) - rejected/被否决的方案如 [rejected/container-default.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/0db7f2de57dd27c80acdc6640cbad0d2) 与 [rejected/standard-distro.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/29b43ab59f2766ce97c185d8fffa4864)。 ## 三、标题与元信息提案的第一印象 模板第一行是 # Your inspiring proposal title自拟的有吸引力的提案标题紧随其后的两行元信息是硬性要求 markdown * First proposed: date * Authors: $full_name (github-handle), $full_name2 (github_handle2)First proposed首次提出日期实际提案中采用YYYY-MM-DD格式如 scheduled-shutdown 提案的2020-04-20Authors作者全名与 GitHub 昵称多作者用逗号分隔。例如多节点提案标注为Sharif Elgamal (sharifelgamal)flake-rate 提案标注为Andriy Dzikh (andriyDev)。这保证后续讨论中评审者知道该向谁提问、谁对该提案负责。需要注意scheduled-shutdown、multinode 等提案还沿用了标题下的元信息格式但并未把Reviewer Priorities的保留指令段落删除——这正是模板下一节强调的要求。四、Reviewer Priorities写给评审者的四把标尺模板中Reviewer Priorities一节是唯一被要求原样保留的内容。模板原文明确写道Please leave the above text in your proposal as instructions to the reader.即提交提案时必须把这四行评审优先级原封不动留在文档里作为给读者的使用说明。这四条评审优先级分别是Does this fit with minikubes principles?—— 方案是否符合 minikube 的设计原则本地开发、简单易用、跨驱动一致等Are there other approaches to consider?—— 是否存在其他候选方案Could the implementation be made simpler?—— 实现能否更简单Are there usability, reliability, or technical debt concerns?—— 是否有可用性、可靠性或技术债隐患。这四条实际上就是评审者拿到任何提案时的默认审查清单。观察仓库中的真实提案从 proposed/20200316-release-schedule/schedule-proposal.md 到 proposed/20201030-tracing/README.md几乎所有文档都原样保留了这段文本这正是模板约束力的体现。五、Summary一段话讲清是什么与为什么模板要求 Summary 用一段话回答两个问题提案是什么为什么对用户/开发者重要看两个成功范例定时关机提案 proposed/20200424-scheduled-shutdown/20200424-scheduled-shutdown.md先用一句Add the ability to schedule a future shutdown or pause event.点明功能再列出两类受益用户——按次调用 minikube 的命令行工具希望在命令间隙保持低延迟和按需启动 minikube 的 IDE并非所有 IDE 都能在关闭时触发退出钩子。一段话同时覆盖是什么和对谁重要两个维度多节点提案 proposed/20200130-multinode/multinode-proposal.md直接点出多节点是 minikube 仓库历史上被请求最多的功能用事实建立提案的正当性。写作要点Summary 不要写实现细节只写给谁带来什么价值。它是评审者最先阅读、也是搜索引擎与后续提案引用最频繁的部分。六、Goals 与 Non-Goals划定提案的边界6.1 Goals具体、可验证的目标模板要求 Goals 是特定的目标列表并且明确追问如何知道这个提案成功了即每个目标都应具备可验证性。以定时关机提案为例其 Goals 精确到行为语义具备调度 pause 或 shutdown 事件的能力具备推迟defer已调度事件的能力minikube start透明地清除所有待执行的调度事件。三条目标全部是可观测行为评审者可以据此判断实现是否达标。6.2 Non-Goals主动声明我不做什么Non-Goals 是模板中极易被新手忽略、却是评审者最看重的一节。模板注释点明了它的作用Listing non-goals helps to focus the discussion列出非目标有助于聚焦讨论。定时关机提案的 Non-Goals 堪称教科书级示范自动空闲检测Automatic idle detection虽然与定时调度互补、且可用同一套机制实现但超出本提案范围自动重新激活Automatic re-activation尤其是定时关机场景下的自动唤醒复杂度显著更高同样排除在外。多节点提案的 Non-Goals 同样简洁Reproducing production environments不追求复现生产环境——一句话就挡住了多节点能否当生产集群用这类发散讨论。从仓库证据看Non-Goals 的价值在于它明确告诉评审者此提案刻意不为某场景负责从而把评审火力集中到真正要解决的问题上。被否决的 rejected/container-default.md 也展示了边界声明的反面价值——该提案明确声明不移除 docker 支持、不改动 docker driver这种边界约束让切换默认 CRI这一激进变更变得可评审。七、Design Details核心设计正文Design Details 是模板中篇幅要求最明确的一节至少 2 段只需包含传达想法所需的细节如果有多个候选实现思路要简洁地并列列出必须包含测试计划确保未来改动不会破坏该增强。7.1 先定义接口再谈实现定时关机提案给出了极佳的写作范式——先定义用户可见的接口再讨论实现方案minikube pause --after 5m minikube stop --after 5m【免费下载链接】minikubeRun Kubernetes locally项目地址: https://gitcode.com/gh_mirrors/mi/minikube创作声明：本文部分内容由AI辅助生成（AIGC），仅供参考
Your inspiring proposal title【免费下载链接】minikubeRun Kubernetes locally项目地址: https://gitcode.com/gh_mirrors/mi/minikubeFirst proposed:Authors: $full_name (github-handle), $full_name2 (github_handle2)Reviewer PrioritiesPlease review this proposal with the following priorities:Does this fit with minikubes principles?Are there other approaches to consider?Could the implementation be made simpler?Are there usability, reliability, or technical debt concerns?Please leave the above text in your proposal as instructions to the reader.Summary(1 paragraph) What are you proposing, and why is it important to users and/or developers?GoalsA bulleted list of specific goals for this proposalHow will we know that this proposal has succeeded?Non-GoalsA bulleted list of what is out of scope for this proposalListing non-goals helps to focus the discussionDesign Details(2 paragraphs) A short overview of your implementation idea, containing only as much detail as required to convey your idea.If you have multiple ideas, list them concisely.Include a testing plan to ensure that your enhancement is not broken by future changes.Alternatives ConsideredAlternative ideas that you are leaning against.模板只解决写什么而放哪里由目录约定决定。仓库中 enhancements/ 目录按生命周期分为三个子目录 - proposed/正在评审中的提案命名规范为 YYYYMMDD-标题/如 [proposed/20200424-scheduled-shutdown/20200424-scheduled-shutdown.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/c8be3abf3389d1abb54831058c2d009b) - implemented/已经实现并合入的提案如 [implemented/20210624-flake-rate/flake-rate.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/1cbd12cf642844c384f9bd92accf58c3) - rejected/被否决的方案如 [rejected/container-default.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/0db7f2de57dd27c80acdc6640cbad0d2) 与 [rejected/standard-distro.md](https://link.gitcode.com/i/29b43ab59f2766ce97c185d8fffa4864)。 ## 三、标题与元信息提案的第一印象 模板第一行是 # Your inspiring proposal title自拟的有吸引力的提案标题紧随其后的两行元信息是硬性要求 markdown * First proposed: date * Authors: $full_name (github-handle), $full_name2 (github_handle2)First proposed首次提出日期实际提案中采用YYYY-MM-DD格式如 scheduled-shutdown 提案的2020-04-20Authors作者全名与 GitHub 昵称多作者用逗号分隔。例如多节点提案标注为Sharif Elgamal (sharifelgamal)flake-rate 提案标注为Andriy Dzikh (andriyDev)。这保证后续讨论中评审者知道该向谁提问、谁对该提案负责。需要注意scheduled-shutdown、multinode 等提案还沿用了标题下的元信息格式但并未把Reviewer Priorities的保留指令段落删除——这正是模板下一节强调的要求。四、Reviewer Priorities写给评审者的四把标尺模板中Reviewer Priorities一节是唯一被要求原样保留的内容。模板原文明确写道Please leave the above text in your proposal as instructions to the reader.即提交提案时必须把这四行评审优先级原封不动留在文档里作为给读者的使用说明。这四条评审优先级分别是Does this fit with minikubes principles?—— 方案是否符合 minikube 的设计原则本地开发、简单易用、跨驱动一致等Are there other approaches to consider?—— 是否存在其他候选方案Could the implementation be made simpler?—— 实现能否更简单Are there usability, reliability, or technical debt concerns?—— 是否有可用性、可靠性或技术债隐患。这四条实际上就是评审者拿到任何提案时的默认审查清单。观察仓库中的真实提案从 proposed/20200316-release-schedule/schedule-proposal.md 到 proposed/20201030-tracing/README.md几乎所有文档都原样保留了这段文本这正是模板约束力的体现。五、Summary一段话讲清是什么与为什么模板要求 Summary 用一段话回答两个问题提案是什么为什么对用户/开发者重要看两个成功范例定时关机提案 proposed/20200424-scheduled-shutdown/20200424-scheduled-shutdown.md先用一句Add the ability to schedule a future shutdown or pause event.点明功能再列出两类受益用户——按次调用 minikube 的命令行工具希望在命令间隙保持低延迟和按需启动 minikube 的 IDE并非所有 IDE 都能在关闭时触发退出钩子。一段话同时覆盖是什么和对谁重要两个维度多节点提案 proposed/20200130-multinode/multinode-proposal.md直接点出多节点是 minikube 仓库历史上被请求最多的功能用事实建立提案的正当性。写作要点Summary 不要写实现细节只写给谁带来什么价值。它是评审者最先阅读、也是搜索引擎与后续提案引用最频繁的部分。六、Goals 与 Non-Goals划定提案的边界6.1 Goals具体、可验证的目标模板要求 Goals 是特定的目标列表并且明确追问如何知道这个提案成功了即每个目标都应具备可验证性。以定时关机提案为例其 Goals 精确到行为语义具备调度 pause 或 shutdown 事件的能力具备推迟defer已调度事件的能力minikube start透明地清除所有待执行的调度事件。三条目标全部是可观测行为评审者可以据此判断实现是否达标。6.2 Non-Goals主动声明我不做什么Non-Goals 是模板中极易被新手忽略、却是评审者最看重的一节。模板注释点明了它的作用Listing non-goals helps to focus the discussion列出非目标有助于聚焦讨论。定时关机提案的 Non-Goals 堪称教科书级示范自动空闲检测Automatic idle detection虽然与定时调度互补、且可用同一套机制实现但超出本提案范围自动重新激活Automatic re-activation尤其是定时关机场景下的自动唤醒复杂度显著更高同样排除在外。多节点提案的 Non-Goals 同样简洁Reproducing production environments不追求复现生产环境——一句话就挡住了多节点能否当生产集群用这类发散讨论。从仓库证据看Non-Goals 的价值在于它明确告诉评审者此提案刻意不为某场景负责从而把评审火力集中到真正要解决的问题上。被否决的 rejected/container-default.md 也展示了边界声明的反面价值——该提案明确声明不移除 docker 支持、不改动 docker driver这种边界约束让切换默认 CRI这一激进变更变得可评审。七、Design Details核心设计正文Design Details 是模板中篇幅要求最明确的一节至少 2 段只需包含传达想法所需的细节如果有多个候选实现思路要简洁地并列列出必须包含测试计划确保未来改动不会破坏该增强。7.1 先定义接口再谈实现定时关机提案给出了极佳的写作范式——先定义用户可见的接口再讨论实现方案minikube pause --after 5m minikube stop --after 5m【免费下载链接】minikubeRun Kubernetes locally项目地址: https://gitcode.com/gh_mirrors/mi/minikube创作声明：本文部分内容由AI辅助生成（AIGC），仅供参考
